• Question: In your opinion to what extent does cultural differences might effect the findings of a psychological study?

    Asked by anon-204913 to Sally, Lucy, Louise, James, David, Dan on 6 Mar 2019.
    • Photo: Lucy Maddox

      Lucy Maddox answered on 6 Mar 2019:


      Fab question and I still don’t think psychological research thinks about this enough. Most studies tend to be with white, middle class participants and then the results get used for lots of different cultural groups. The beliefs we have are often shaped by our cultures and might lead us to behave in different ways and feel different things in response to certain situations, so it’s really important that cultural differences are taken into account.
      This is certainly true in relation to attitudes to therapy. A colleague of mine held a series of talks in a Mosque in Glasgow last year to try to explore how spirituality fits with more psychological understandings of mental health problems. I interviewed the speakers about it in this podcast if you’re interested: http://letstalkaboutcbt.libsyn.com/lets-talk-about-cbt-outreach-event

    • Photo: James Munro

      James Munro answered on 6 Mar 2019: last edited 6 Mar 2019 4:01 pm


      Excellent question, and Lucy is right. Psychology can often ignore this issue. Usually it is ignored because it is expensive and difficult to study cultures that are different to our own. I am currently doing research to find out what percentage of psychology studies are conducted using white, female, young, university student and western (rich, democratic, industrialised) societies. The limited scope of psychology is a problem, but pretending there is not a problem is much worse.

      There is some research that shows that participants from western, mainly white, mainly rich democratic countries are actually really weird compared to participants from other societies https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X0999152X

      P.s. Lucy, that podcast was really interesting. Thank you!

    • Photo: Dan Taylor

      Dan Taylor answered on 6 Mar 2019:


      I would start by echoing a lot of what Lucy and James have said.
      A really good example of this is when we look at the dark triad of personality (psychopathy, narcissism and Machiavellianism or social manipulation), most studies have suggested that men score more highly than women, however these studies have primarily used undergraduate university students. When these studies are replicated in the general population (for example people not at university) the results tend to show that this is not the case.
      Psychology does suffer with Eurocentricism (a focus on Western or European culture), a good example can be when we look at things like mindfulness – it incorporates a lot of Eastern meditation (from Buddhism) into its philosophy, and does show to be quite helpful. Often this gets “modified” to fit into busy Western life, and it becomes less effective.
      We also see things like attachment style differ depending on if a culture is collectivist (cultures focusing on the group, often these are Eastern cultures) or individualist (cultures focusing on the individual, often these are Western cultures) but most of the research into attachment style has been done in the West!

    • Photo: Sally Tilt

      Sally Tilt answered on 6 Mar 2019:


      Great answers by Lucy, James and Dan. Just a little add for a forensic psychology example. One of the widely used tools for assessing psychopathy (the Psychopathy Checklist Revised) – was originally developed on an American population, and then used in the UK. Interestingly, once it had been used widely, and a large amount of data was available – researchers noticed that the way that Scottish populations tended to score on the checklist was different to the populations in England and the US. As a result it is suggested that the cut-off score for the assessment is different if the tool is being used with a Scottish population. A recent study has just suggested a different cut off when using the tool in Brazil. This highlights the importance of understanding what a study can and cannot tell us and how it might be necessary to validate findings with different groups.

    • Photo: David Chadwick

      David Chadwick answered on 11 Mar 2019:


      I am not a psychologist, so my answer is that of a lay person rather than a professional. But I suspect that cultural differences will effect any psychological study, because you set the context for the study using your own cultural context. If someone comes at it from a difference cultural context, then they are bound to interpret the questions differently and therefore produce different answers.

    • Photo: Louise Rodgers

      Louise Rodgers answered on 11 Mar 2019: last edited 11 Mar 2019 10:44 am


      You’ve got some really thorough answers from the other psychologists and if you’re designing a research project in the future and you’ve already started to think about this and about biases in research, you’ve already got a very high level of insight and reflection and I predict you’ll do brilliantly!

      If you’re interested in reading more about avoiding biases you might be interested in this article https://digest.bps.org.uk/2016/12/22/introductory-psychology-books-accused-of-spreading-myths-and-left-leaning-bias/

Comments